Welcome, have fun discussing the books etc. Remember your views count .
New spammer counter-measures are in place … captcha removed. Because spammers are so tenacious I am now moderating the first few posts. This should eliminate the Spam you see, for the new non-spammers you have my apologies.
For assistance please email admin (at) this domain. (sorry but I am not going to make it easy for spiders to spam me )
I'm confused. In the beginning of the book, Lissa writes in her journal that she recognized Ashe, but the Mighty Mind was unfamiliar to her. At the end, Charles is revealed to be the Mighty Mind. Surely Lissa would recognize Charles. What am I missing? Admittedly, I devoured the new book and am rereading it now, but a little help with this would be nice. Thank you.
Lissa writes in her journal that she recognized Ashe, but the Mighty Mind was unfamiliar to her. At the end, Charles is revealed to be the Mighty Mind. Surely Lissa would recognize Charles.
Charles was the disguise that the Mind was using. As the Three are some of the most powerful around, they are able to disguise themselves in such a way that even the Godlings like Lissa can't see through them. Yes, Lissa would recognise Charles, but she wouldn't be able to see that the Charles persona wasn't real, that it was merely a cover for someone else. Hope I explained that ok. As I remember, at the moment that Charles, Bree and Ashe were all drawn together, Charles dropped his disguise the moment that they all formed as the One. This is the Mind we are talking about, he probably knew from a very early age what was going on and could have adopted the Charles disguise then. I suppose an alternative is that Charles and the Mind disguised as Charles are two separate beings. Personally I hope for the latter otherwise it would mean that all of the wrong Charles witnessed, to Lissa and to others, could have been prevented and he didn't. Time will tell I suppose.
I'm having trouble with the Three forming into the One at the moment. The problem i'm having is that I do not see any reason why they can't separate again. We already know that the Three were destined to work together, well this could well be that "together", literally. We are all putting stock in the reactions of other characters in the book, but, when you think about it they know as little about the natures of the one and the Three as we do and nothing so far has indicated that this is a permanent change. No one, including Belen has anything more to go on than the rumours and legends passed down the ages as to what the Three can and can't do. Granted Belen is possibly the most informed but even he doesn't know if this is a permanent thing. Remember the last words of Charles. He said it "was and wasn't" time for him to reveal himself. That in no way indicates that this was not on the cards. Bree has 20 mates, surely the love of all those mates would be enough to pull her free of the merging. Ashe has Kay and vast strength... Charles has knowledge and understanding. I don't know, maybe it is wishful thinking on my part but the whole idea of this being a permanent thing doesn't make any sense to me at all. I fully expect them to just separate and reform as individuals.
Always enjoy reading your posts Larry - you always find things that i never even thought of like Saxom / Moxas.
Share it like you used to damn it.....pweeeese..... with sugar on top.
@Larry -- LOL that was one of my brain benders in this book. The first few times my subconscious noticed, but I didn't get it. Finally it clicked after several mentions. And it totally had me laughing - twins and all that.